| Player | Made | Years |
|---|---|---|
| Morten Andersen | 302 | 1982-1994 |
| John Carney | 168 | 2001-2006, 09-10 |
| Doug Brien | 123 | 1995-2000 |
| Will Lutz | 119 | 2016-2019 |
| Garrett Hartley | 82 | 2008-2013 |
| Charlie Durkee | 52 | 1967-68, 71-72 |
| Tom Dempsey | 40 | 1969-1970 |
| Rich Szaro | 37 | 1975-1978 |
| Shayne Graham | 24 | 2013-2014 |
| Bill McClard | 23 | 1973-1975 |
| Benny Ricardo | 23 | 1980-1981 |
| Martin Gramatica | 11 | 2007-2008 |
